| 2025 Ryan Prior, Virginia 2024 Sean Griggs, Alabama Rory Finn, Delaware2023 |
| Toby Smith, Elon University Luke Roccesano, Maryland University Frank Scrivanic, Seton Hall University John Goodes, Rutgers Shaun O'Keeffe, George Mason Anthony Marano, William & Mary Jason Basilicata, STAC Christopher Manco, Stevenson University Charlie Tallman, Sacred Heart University Cal Champeau, Skidmore College Anthony Bubba, University of Hartford |
| 2022 |
| Zach Crotchfelt, Auburn University |
| Andrew Fischer, Duke University |
| Andrew Argenziano, Columbia |
| Logan Duffy, Old Dominion University |
| James Asleta, Lafayette College |
| Matt Scrivanic, Monmouth University |
| Jack Frankovic, Lehigh |
| Owen West, NJIT |
| Shaun O'Keeffe, George Mason Kyle Pollack, Marist College Zach McCabe, Stockton Luca Marshall, Franklin & Marshall Evan Bresnen, Kean University Joe Girori, Brookdale CC Jack Zabarsky, Montclair State University Joey Gmitter, Mercer CC Brian Yadlon, Ocean County CC Ben "Reuben" Cacoilo, Drew University Dylan Wangiel, Ocean County CC Derek Baksh, Kings College Jerry Winchester, York College Sean McAllister, Franklin & Marshall Ryan Turner, Penn State Harrisburg Nicolas Galvan, Monmouth University Shane Sajewicz, TCNJ Nick LoVarco, Brookdale Jake Burt, University of Hartford |
| 2021 |
| Mikey Bello, Auburn University |
| Shane Panzini, University of Virginia |
| Jay Bant, Monmouth University |
| Andrew Schmid, Monmouth University |
| Max Harrell, University of Charleston WV |
| Mike Gallaro, Salve Regina |
| Henry Escandon, Catholic University |
| Will Tierney, Salve Regina |
| Gavin Martin, UMASS |
| Griffin Murphy, Arcadia University |
| Chris Ellison, Cornell University |
| Sean O'Mara, Catholic University |
| Tyler Hmiewlewski, Susquehanna University |
| Jordan Nitti, Stockon University |
| Brandon Hulsart, Centenary University |
| Kiernan Hollander, Ursinus College |
| David Appolonia, Cumberland CC |
| Dylan Sakele, Stockton University |
| Matt Villapiano, Stevens Institute of Technology |
| Bobby Nosti, Stockton University |
| Luke Mulhern, Muhlenberg College |
| David Ventura, Stockton University |
| Lucky Perrotto, Catholic University |
| Austin Jack, Misercordia University |
| Lucas Malave, Catholic University |
| Evan Pollack, Stockton University |
| Dylan Wanagiel, Ocean County College |
| Kevin Novoblisky, Stockton University |
| Jarek Vargas, Lincoln College Riley Supp, Eastern University |
| 2020 |
| Alex Galvan, University of Louisville |
| Tommy Talbott, Stockton University |
| Julianna Green, Berry College |
| Kyle Vinci, Princeton University |
| Jacob Sloss, UMass |
| Ben Chrzanowski, UMass |
| Timmy McEneny, Cornell University |
| Mike Farinaccio, Alvernia University |
| Christian McElroy, Alvernia University |
| Michael Montenegro, NYU |
| Patrick Apgar, University of New Orleans |
| Jack Scrivanic, Wagner College |
| Jordan Jurkiewicz, University of Delaware |
| Brett Wichrowski, Bryant University |
| Mason Wolf, Monmouth University |
| Collin Turner, Catholic University |
| Bayron Lopez, Alvernia University |
| Rody Martinez, CCM |
| Michael Murphy, Montclair University |
| Will Hopkinson, Brookdale CC |
| Chris O'Connor, University of Albany |
| Matt Vernieri, Bloomsburg |
| Noah Dean, Old Dominion University |
| Kevin Schoenberger, Dominican College |
| Daniel Greene, Rutgers Newark |
| Robert Jeans, Belmont Abbey College |
| Ryan Chin, Steven's Institute of Technology
|
| 2019 |
| Ron Cole, University of Kentucky |
| Tate Ballestero, University of Virginia |
| Johnny Volpe, Rider University |
| Joey Ventressca, Monmouth University |
| Robby Zega, James Madison University |
| Max Winters, William & Mary University |
| Gerry Peacock, Notre Dame |
| Ervin Bogan Jr., George Washington University |
| Liam Simon, Notre Dame |
| Aurelio Licata, Seton Hall University |
| Vinny Bianchi, St. John's University (Drafted 35th Round Los Angeles Angels) |
| Eliot Dix, Longwood University |
| Pat DeSalvo, Georgetown |
| Tommy Mayer, William & Mary University |
| David Glancy, St. John's University |
| Nick Estes, Montlcair State University |
| Kenny Quijano, Rider University |
| Sam Angelo, Montclair State University |
| Luke Fabrizzi, Stockton University |
| Connor Baksh, Delaware State University |
| Sebastian JnoBaptiste, College of New Jersey |
| Andrew Connallon, Moravian College |
| Patrick Leighton, Neumann University |
| Jake Smyrl, Montclair State University |
| Connor Coyle, Arcadia University |
| Matteo Sollectio, Swarthmore College |
| Robert Arena Jr., Muhlenberg
|
| 2018 |
| Peter Serruto, Rutgers University (Drafted by Cincinnati Red 22nd Round) |
| Brendan Mullins, Penn State |
| Jack Zyska, Notre Dame |
| Blaise Panzini, Seton Hall University |
| Joseph Acosta, East Tennessee State University |
| Will Gannon, Bucknell University |
| Riley Maypother, East Tennessee State University |
| Pat Harrington, Dickinson College |
| Giuseppe Arcuri, East Tennessee State University |
| Jacob Birnbaum, Dickinson College |
| Austin Ferrier, James Madison University |
| Brody Maypother, Kings University |
| Austin Nappi, Catholic University of America |
| Robby Smith, Dickinson College |
| Frank DelGuercio, Rider University |
| Jimmy Frein, Brookdale |
| Ryan Sheppard, Montclair State University |
| Jon Michael Rotundo, Rutgers Camden University |
| Dane "Ramtown" DellaValle, Johnson & Wales University |
| Brendan Doherty, Stockton University |
| Keith Apostolos, Brookdale |
| Colin Stacy, Arcadia University |
| Mike Walsh, Brookdale |
| Kylie McCabe, Clark University |
| Jillian Bigos, William Paterson |
| Danielle Britton, College of New Jersey |
| Samantha Britton, Eastern University |
| Danielle Kroll, Caldwell University
|
| 2017 |
| Constantine "Andrew" Papantonis, University of Virginia |
| Brendan Hueth, St. Joseph University |
| Hunter Waldis, Seton Hall University |
| Brad Dobzanski, University of Kentucky (Drafted by the San Francisco Giants 39th Round) |
| Matt Fahey, Manhattan College |
| Christian Piantino, Trinity College |
| Ryan Vatcher, Babson College |
| Billy Russo, Lafayette College |
| Connor Muly, Old Dominion University |
| Eddie Barnwell, DeSales University |
| Aiden Supp, Montclair State University |
| Winston Allen, University of Delaware |
| Francis Prior, NYU |
| Dom Caraballo, Rider University |
| Jack DeSalvo, Washington University |
| Justin Fiume, Bard College |
| Joe Volpe, Dickinson College |
| Mike Miles, Barry University |
| Kelly Duffy, Rowan University |
| Giovanna Russomano- Felician University
|
| 2016 |
| Anthony Condito, Rutgers University |
| Jack Ipsen, Bryant University |
| Gavin Hollowell, St. John's University |
| Regan Dombroski, Monmouth University |
| Kenny Mendoza, Campbell University (Drafted by the Texas Rangers 24th Round) |
| Jordan Hutchins, Delaware University |
| Mason Hickman, Vanderbilt |
| Justin Rouse, Coastal Carolina |
| Tyler Shedler, Seton Hall |
| John Zega, Monmouth University |
| Steve Bowley, Wagner College |
| Evan Madigan, Bucknell University |
| Noah Abdalla, Georgetown |
| Kyle Johnson, Rider University |
| Philip Clarke, Vanderbilt |
| Pete "Boomer" Soporowski, Rider University |
| Matt Dipasupil, James Madison University |
| John Poccia, DeSales University |
| Kenny Campbell, Lafayete College |
| Claudio LoBraico, Swarthmore College |
| Grant Otto, Oberlin College |
| Cole Fluta, Brookdale / Texas A&M Corpus Christi |
| Andrew Keenan, Union College |
| Ryan Yee, University of NY Maritime College |
| Devin McLaughlin, Juniata College |
| Doug Facendo, Howard CC/ Texas Tech |
| Hunter Abdalla, Tulane |
| Elijah Tait, William Paterson University |
| Zachary King, Vanderbilt
|
| 2015 |
| Will Morgan, Old Dominion University |
| Andrew Miller, Maryland University/University of Kentucky (Drafted by the New York Yankees 34th Rd) |
| Morgan Maguire, Old Dominion University |
| Dan Wondrack, The College of Charleston |
| Brandon Janofsky, Stony Brook University |
| Brett Hyers, UNC Asheville |
| Doug Molnar, Wagner College |
| Anthony Morrone, Lehigh University |
| Jay Sanford, Towson University |
| Jason Applegate, Villanova University |
| Aaron Portee, Akron University |
| Max Goione, Siena College |
| Ryan Larsen, Steven's Institute of Technology |
| Joe Silverstrone, Wagner College |
| Vahaka Hovanian, Gettysburg College |
| Jack Nelson, Boston College |
| Spencer Kapp, NJIT
|
| 2014 |
| Al Molina, Coastal Carolina University (Drafted by Philadelphia Phillies) |
| Mike Alescio, Seton Hall University (Signed Professional Contract Milwaukee Brewers) |
| Shane McCarthy, Seton Hall University ( Drafted by the St. Louis Cardinals 18th Round) |
| Bryan Dobzanski, Louisville University (Drafted by the St. Louis Cardinals) |
| John Malatesta, NJIT |
| Devin Tomei, Campbell University |
| Russell Messler, Rutgers University |
| Kyle Brey, Wagner College |
| Mike Zibrin, Rutgers-Newark |
| Mike Bartels, Washington College |
| Nick Horvath, Santa Fe College/ University of Florida |
| Antonio Cox, South Alabama University |
| Nick Cardace, Arcadia University |
| Mike Zibrin, Rutgers Newark
|
| 2013 |
| Matt Pidich, University of Pittsburgh (Drafted by Cincinnati Reds 8th Round) |
| Mike Rescigno, Maryland University (Drafted by the San Francisco Giants 28th Round) |
| Jake Yanez, NJIT |
| Frank Maldonado, University of Pittsburgh |
| Brett Mele, Hamilton University |
| Jason Lundy, Fordham University |
| Chris Stark, University of Maine |
| Matt Kleinstein, West Virginia University |
| Jake Spezial, Brown University |
| Jon Baturgil, Long Island University |
| Joe Iacobellis, Alvernia University |
| Mike Marley, Penn State-Altoona |
| Dan Maguire, Keystone College
|
| 2012 |
| Jackson Kramer, Lafayette University |
| Ryan McNally, Fordham University |
| Andrew LaMura, East Carolina University |
| Colin Perro, Monmouth University |
| Sean Arnott, Temple University |
| Brian Lamboy, Sacred Heart University |
| Tyler Saito, Monmouth University |
| Carmine Palummo, Iona University |
| Ryan Spahr, Wagner College |
| Matt Osgoodby, Alvernia University |
| Eric Scamerdella, Catholic University |
| Nick Liggett, University of Delaware |
| Dylan Baxter, Drew University |
| Ryan Mihalkovitz, Pace University |
| Dan Sweeney, Richard Stockton College of NJ |
| Howie Brey, Rutgers University (Drafted by the Houston Astros 31st Round) |
| Diego Espinosa, Brookdale / FDU
|
| 2011 |
| Ryan Kirman, University. of Connecticut |
| Vinny Tranchina, St. John's University/ Long Island University |
| Mike Rytelewski, Montclair State |
| Ben Musicant, Siena College |
| Jon Roszel, West Virginia University/ Flaglar College |
| Nick Lustrino, Temple University/ Old Dominion University |
| Shawn Weeks, FAU |